FOR REVIEWERS Submit Review of Manuscript Manuscript Title * Reviewer * Is the manuscript consistent with the purpose of the journal? * Yes Yes No No Is the manuscript dependable in method, data and documentation? * Yes Yes No No If "no", identify your concerns After reviewing the manuscript, select a rating: * Outstanding; advances CST in an original way Outstanding; advances CST in an original way Excellent; first-rate scholarship worthy of publication Excellent; first-rate scholarship worthy of publication Above average; solid scholarship that advances knowledge Above average; solid scholarship that advances knowledge Acceptable; good scholarship that covers or restates existing perspectives Acceptable; good scholarship that covers or restates existing perspectives Acceptable with significant revision Acceptable with significant revision Unacceptable Unacceptable If you selected "acceptable" or better, suggest additions, deletions or other changes: If you selected “acceptable with significant revision,” recommend how the manuscript should be reworked and assess its potential if revised: If you selected "unacceptable," please give specific rationale: Upload feedback in Word doc or PDF if comments exceed 250 words Upload author's manuscript with comments, if applicable Submit Reset SUBSCRIBE CONTRIBUTE REVIEW
